Saturday, April 4, 2009

Bucka Fairy?

I know, it has been ages since I have had any food for thought. If it makes you feel better, I was also having trouble finding food for nourishment. I am doing better now, thanks for asking, and am enjoying cooking again as well as eating.

I finally have both kids down, Dapo is gone and it is just me! I really have been spending most of my time on facebook and putting most of my thoughts up there...so I now have a story to tell on my blog.

When I was a kid my parents taught me about Santa. Every Christmas we'd write our Christmas letter to Santa, along with one item we wanted Santa to bring us. On Christmas Eve we'd make cookies and leave one out with a glass of milk. We would hang stockings on the chimney with care. We awoke with great anticipation on Christmas morning to find the cookies were gone and find the aforementioned stockings loaded with goodies and fruit and perhaps a small toy. Santa was so good about bringing exactly what I had asked for! Christmas was the most wonderful time of the year!

When I was in the third grade I would have been 8, almost 9 years old. I was going to a private school at the time and we were learning songs for the Christmas special. I said something about Santa, and one of the boys in class told me "There is no such thing as Santa, stupid!" The whole class laughed and laughed about how funny it was that Kari still believed in Santa. What's worse, I defended my views retorting, "Of course there's a Santa, who puts presents under your tree, then?" "Your parents, DUH!" More laughter ensued. So now not only was I humiliated, but I had learned that my parents had been lying to me for over 8 years. NO SANTA?? Why had they done this to me?!

The teacher actually had to take me into the hall and calm me down because I was crying and she knew that I had just had my little world shook upside down. Of course, this is the same teacher who would smack your knuckles with a ruler if you got out of line, but today she was emoting compassion.

I wound up forgiving my parents, but promised myself I would never do that to my children. No Santa. No Easter Bunny. No Tooth Fairy. I just didn't see any reason to make up a lie just to let them down later. I would have been just fine if my parents had eaten the cookies, stuffed the stocking and bought the present all those years.

But what about the Binky Fairy??? This last week has been a hard week on all of us as we've taken the pacifier away from Jimi. He was rather attached to it. I've had several people suggest we explain to him the binky fairy has come and taken the binkies away and gave them to other little babies. It worked for them, they say!

I'm torn by this for two reasons. One, I think Jimi would not be as giving as my friends' children. I think the sight of the binky (or bucka, as he calls it) would send him into a tissy. Two, I think the Binky Fairy would have to fall into the same category as Santa, the Easter Bunny and the Tooth Fairy. You know, a convenient lie I tell to make it easier to live amongst the status quo? To each his own.

Thanks for the suggestions, though. I think I will just have to tough it out and keep singing him to sleep until he gets over it. He still asks for it at every nap and bedtime. He also asks for it at various intervals during the day. He has torn up the house three days in a row looking for it in every drawer he can open (and he can open them all ever since he figured out how to open the "childproof locks").

I take solace in the fact I am doing the best thing for him, even if it is hard on me.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

We did the Santa, Easter Bunny, Tooth Fairy things with the kids, but we told them the truth quite early (1st and 3rd grade). They didn't fuss or cry about it. They enjoy being part of the "secret" and do their best to support their cousins' belief. They STILL put out cookies and milk for Santa and put teeth under their pillows for the Tooth Fairy. They like the "game" of it :)
Tim and I struggled more with the idea not because of worrying about humiliation but because we didn't want them to be puting the imaginary Santa and Easter Bunny on even par with God. I would say this actually puts God at a disadvantage because Santa and the Easter Bunny pay off in tangible (and often yummy chocolate) way, while God's gifts are much harder for a child to see.
So, if you don't feel comfortable with the Binky Fairy, then you shouldn't do it. He will grow out of this phase, just like kids always do, and be a o.k. Besides, just doing something because it's easy, isn't always the best course...wide road, anyone?? ;-)
We weaned our twins off the binky at around 2. I cut the nipple part off and gave it to them same as always. They got very frustrated with it because they couldn't suck on it (I left just enough to tease them, but not enough for them to actually suck on). After a couple of days they weren't sleeping with them in their mouths and by Day 4 they voluntarily threw them away. I made EXTRA sure to not have any around, lest I fall back on it or have them discover one :) You are at a disadvantage because you have another little one around.
Big ((HUGS)) for you mama...you're doing well!!

Anonymous said...

I'm with you on this one Kari... Ryken still has his binky for a nap and night time. He only gets it while sleeping. I am dreading taking it all the way away and I know he is way overdue for it. I think the only thing that will work for him is a HUGE bribe.